Paragard: Are you hurt?
Prone to breaking – Women who used Paragard are now filing lawsuits due to complications. After the birth control device was implanted the suffering began.
See if you qualify. Time is limited. Get a free case review now
See if you Qualify
Take our 1-minute quiz
In short: What is wrong with Paragard
A number of women implanted with the birth control IUD Paragard have suffered a broad range of medical issues caused by the intended use of the product, including fractures, ectopic pregnancy and other complications.
Plaintiffs are claiming that the grievous injuries they endured resulted from certain copper based IUDs like Paragard being defective and prone to breakage, resulting in these dangerous side effects.
If you or a loved one suffered an injury after receiving a Paragard IUD device for preventing pregnancy, you may be eligible for compensation.
Current state of the legal proceedings [January 2022]
Currently, attorneys are trying to hold Teva Pharmaceuticals liable for injuries sustained through the use of the .
Below are the latest updates on the Paragard litigation. We constantly update this page whenever new information is available. Make sure to check this page from time to time to keep up with the latest updates on the lawsuits.
November 2021 update: The judge denied defendants’ motion to dismiss all cases against them. Defendants Teva Pharmaceuticals and CooperSurgical argued that complaints in the were “shotgun pleadings.”
In other words, the two big defendants argue that the claims didn’t have enough factual details to state a valid tort claim. However, Judge May rejected this argument.
According to her, the plaintiffs have adequately stated their claims and at this point, it cannot be determined whether the design defect and failure to warn claims are preempted by federal law. It was obvious from the start that the Georgia federal judge seemed to be unmoved by the defense arguments and had no plans of granting the dismissals.
Instead, she seems much more interested in selecting and scheduling cases for the first bellwether trials.
Lawyers accuse the pharmaceutical company of releasing a to market, focusing squarely on Teva’s negligence in warning the public about Paragard’s potential dangers.
In December 2020, the JPML centralized all Paragard cases to be tried together in the of Georgia in front of Judge Leigh Martin May. This may facilitate settlement discussions, but the process is just beginning.
This process may mirror the Mirena litigation, where, due to the large number of women injured by the device, a plethora of lawsuits had already reached a number of district federal courts.
The Judicial Panel on (JPML) consolidated them into the MDL No. 2434 in the Southern District of New York back in 2017. At least 2,700 women have sued Bayer over these adverse events. Some of these cases settled in 2018 for $12.2 million, but the settlement only included claims related to IUD migration and perforation. Bayer’s 2018 settlement did not settle any cases related to pseudotumor cerebri.
What is Paragard and how does it work?
Paragard is a long-term birth control method known as an intrauterine device (IUD). The basic design includes a copper wire coiled around a T-shaped plastic base, which is inserted into a woman’s uterus by a doctor. Paragard is a medical device that prevents pregnancy with alleged effectiveness of 99%. The mechanism for the IUD to work is a slow release of copper over 10 years.
Once the device is implanted in the uterine cavity, it interferes with the fertilization of the egg by blocking sperm movement after intercourse. In addition to simply blocking sperm from reaching the uterus, Copper is somewhat toxic, and according to the manufacturer’s published instructions and warnings, Paragard’s copper is designed to cause an inflammatory reaction in the uterus, preventing the egg from attaching. This is not a side effect or complication, but the very method through which Paragard is designed to prevent pregnancy by stopping egg fertilization.
There are two different models of Paragard: the Copper 380 Slimline and the Copper 380A. The device is manufactured by Teva Pharmaceuticals, and it was first released it into the American market in 1988.
Why is Paragard dangerous?
According to recently filed complaints, the Paragard intrauterine contraceptive device is prone to breaking inside the body of the woman who had it implanted. This may lead to serious Paragard IUD complications, including the device becoming embedded inside the uterus, perforating it, and causing serious injuries to the patient due to fragment migration.
Many Paragard users reported that the device can also break during the removal procedure, and when that happens, the broken pieces must be painfully removed one by one with a complicated medical procedure necessary to avoid organ damage.
In some instances, the fragments of a broken Paragard IUD device can become embedded so deeply inside the woman’s tissue that a total hysterectomy (removal of the uterus) is required, with devastating psychological and physical consequences.
If a Paragard IUD breaks, the risks of additional side effects rise dramatically. Some related side effects are infection, scarring, idiopathic intracranial hypertension, and ectopic pregnancy. This type of pregnancy occurs outside the uterus, most often in a fallopian tube. Since the fetus can’t develop normally, it may cause potentially fatal internal bleeding in the mother and must be removed as urgently as possible.
Are the other IUD devices safe?
Paragard isn’t the only dangerous IUD device that hit the American market. Mirena, a similar device manufactured by Bayer, has been associated with a staggering number of complications and adverse reports (nearly 50,000) since the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approved it back in 2000.
Although Mirena’s contraceptive power is based on a different principle (using small quantities of the hormone levonorgestrel in the bloodstream rather than copper), this alternative device is no less dangerous. In fact, this T-shaped device may also detach from its implanted position, causing gruesome organ injuries such as the perforation of the fallopian tubes or the uterus. Mirena is also associated with another serious condition called pseudotumor cerebri (PTC), a buildup of pressure in the brain. It is also known as idiopathic intracranial hypertension (IIH).
Differences between Mirena and Paragard
The main difference between Paragard and Mirena is that Paragard uses copper to prevent pregnancy while Mirena uses synthetic hormones. Both are made primarily of plastic, but Paragard incorporates copper wire coiled around the frame. Paragard lasts 10 years – twice the 5 years of Mirena’s duration.
Why you should file a Paragard lawsuit?
According to court filings, Teva was fully aware of the risks associated with the use or removal of Paragard, and willfully downplayed or ignored them. While the manufacturer described Paragard as a safe method of birth control, important data about its numerous complications has never been fully disclosed. Attorneys allege that the manufacturer obtained sufficient information about the alleged dangers of the IUD device from both post-marketing experience, medical product safety network data, and clinical trials. However, Teva remained focused on the bottom line, never warning women about potentially serious risks of using Paragard for contraception. The defective product has never been subject to either a manufacturer or FDA recall.
Medical device manufacturers like Teva must be held liable for the injuries they caused you or your loved one. Litigation is often the only way to seek justice. Importantly, if you or someone you love has been impacted by using Paragard or any other IUD, a lawyer may help you receive adequate financial compensation for your pain and suffering. But the clock is ticking. Call today if you believe you or someone you love has been injured by using the Paragard IUD.
How Much Money Can I Get in a Paragard Settlement?
As of today, it’s difficult to estimate just how much Teva Pharmaceuticals may pay if the mass tort is eventually settled. Settlement discussions are unique for each mass tort case, so predicting settlements is usually a fool’s errand. Usually, the manufacturers of allegedly defective devices offer an individual agreement to each injured victim only if the first few bellwether cases do not end in their favor. Judge May is likely to set a schedule for these bellwether trials and the case generally in the first quarter of 2021.
However, due to the striking similarities with the Mirena litigation, we may expect the trials to end in a similar way. During the ongoing Mirena litigation, Bayer paid $12.2 million to settle devices migration cases in August 2017.
What is the expected payout per person in the Paragard lawsuit?
Awards in this kind of case are unpredictable and will be based on the specific facts of your specific case. In other words, even if your case is successful, and a court awards you damages, the individual payout you will receive will vary significantly. While global settlements are a possibility, it remains much more likely that each IUD lawsuit will be analyzed separately, and the value of your claim will depend on the details of your particular situation.
Your lawyer will be able to help you recover more if you suffered more economic, personal, physical or emotional damage. Factors such as pain and suffering, loss of consortium, loss of wages and medical expenses need to be considered before your financial reward is calculated under the terms of a settlement agreement or a verdict at trial.
Written by: Barbara Fuller
Edited by: Jeff Keiser
- 1 Paragard: Are you hurt?
- 2 See if you Qualify
- 3 In short: What is wrong with Paragard
- 4 Current state of the legal proceedings [January 2022]
- 5 What is Paragard and how does it work?
- 6 Why is Paragard dangerous?
- 7 Are the other IUD devices safe?
- 8 Differences between Mirena and Paragard
- 9 Why you should file a Paragard lawsuit?
- 10 How Much Money Can I Get in a Paragard Settlement?
- 11 What is the expected payout per person in the Paragard lawsuit?
- 12 Were you harmed?
Were you harmed?
Drugwatcher helps you to stand up against producers of dangerous drugs and medical devices.
Contact us now
Are you hurt?
Fill out form
See if you or a loved one qualify for compensation
Please fill out our form
Fill out form
Serious side effects with Paragard are more rare but can occur. These include ectopic pregnancy (pregnancy outside of the uterus), septic abortion, severe infection called sepsis, pelvic inflammatory disease, and perforation or embedment in the uterus.Is there a recall for copper IUD? ›
Paragard has not been recalled for breakage issues and has no other recent recalls. The device is still available on the market.Did Paragard get recalled? ›
Paragard has not been recalled, but that does not mean it did not cause you harm. If you were injured by a Paragard IUD, you have rights, including the right to file a lawsuit against those responsible for your suffering.Can Paragard cause scarring? ›
It may move outside the uterus and cause scarring, infection, damage to other organs, pain, or infertility. Surgery may be needed. Excessive pain or vaginal bleeding during placement of Paragard, pain or bleeding that gets worse after placement, or not being able to feel the threads may happen with perforation.Can Paragard cause copper toxicity? ›
Paragard, which manufactures copper IUDs, warns that women should not use the copper IUD if they have a copper allergy, however there is no mention of the risk of copper toxicity.Can you get copper toxicity from IUD? ›
There's no clear evidence that copper IUDs significantly increase the risk of copper toxicity in the blood, unless you already have a condition that affects your liver's ability to process copper. However, there may be other side effects when using a copper IUD.